FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 |

«Empowered Learning: Fostering Thinking Across the Curriculum Violet H. Harada, Associate Professor Library & Information Science Program Department ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Empowered Learning: Fostering Thinking Across the Curriculum

Violet H. Harada, Associate Professor

Library & Information Science Program

Department of Information & Computer Sciences

University of Hawaii

Most people will finish their formal education between the ages of 18 and

22. Today’s young adults are expected to have the longest average life

span in the history of the world, with most living into their 70s and many

living into their 80s and 90s. We can only guess what life will be like in the years 2050 or beyond. One likely prediction is that many of today’s young adults will be working at jobs that currently don’t exist and dealing with technologies that dwarf the imagination of present-day science fiction writers. What do they need to learn during their first two decades of life that will prepare them for their remaining years? (Halpern, 1997, 3) As society changes, the skills that citizens need to negotiate the complexities of life also change. Bransford (1999) states that in the early 1900s, a person who had acquired simple reading, writing, and calculating skills was considered literate. Today, however, the public education system expects all students to achieve higher levels of proficiency in reading critically, writing persuasively, thinking and reasoning logically, and solving complex problems.

There is certainly no dearth of ideas about what constitutes learning that is essential for the Information Age. The North Central Regional Educational Laboratory, for example, identifies the following literacies to “improve the intellectual capital” of the 21st century citizenry: basic language proficiency;

knowledge of scientific thinking; competence in the use of computer applications;

ability to decipher, interpret, and express ideas through visual media; global appreciation of the cultural diversity of peoples and cultures; and proficiency in locating, evaluating and using information (NCREL, n.d.).

For the last two decades, schools across the nation have been engaged in standards-based reform in an attempt to conceptualize and to clarify what should be taught in our schools. This has resulted in a plethora of standards for curriculum and learning developed at the national, state, district, and even school levels.

Although these various standards have yielded a rich set of alternatives for schools to design dynamic curricula, reform scholars contend that they have also resulted in a fragmented profusion that often confuses educators and the public (Newmann, 1996; Perkins, 1992; Sternberg, 1992). Wiske maintains that teachers surrounded by “curriculum materials, standardized test mandates, daily schedules, and years of experience that reinforce traditional transmission-based instruction,” are understandably bewildered (1998, 3). What ultimately results in the name of reform is nothing more than “irregular waves of change [and] episodic projects” (Fullan, 1993, 49). Ironically, we are victims of the information glut we often associate with the Digital Age. As one teacher wondered aloud at a meeting I recently attended, “We have over 400 standards for ten content areas in our state! Where do we start?” Indeed, where do we start? For library media specialists, this question has special urgency. In many schools, we are perceived as providers of ancillary (and dispensable) services and gatekeepers of underused collections (DeGroff, 1997;

Wolcott, Lawless, & Hobbs, 1999). In many districts and states, lack of funds and qualified personnel have resulted in schools without functioning library media centers. Rather than viewing this state of affairs as a “bad thing,” Johnson maintains that “our vulnerability demands that we as a profession need to continually find ways to strengthen our programs and roles” (2002, 21).

In reform efforts on all school campuses, library media specialists must see beyond the rhetoric of nurturing lifelong learning and begin asking ourselves deeper questions about what that learning really looks like and how we help to achieve it.

Although all standards include information literacy, the connection with the library media program is “implied rather than stated” (Kearney, 2000, 87). The pervasive yet transparent nature of information literacy standards makes it imperative that we review our own state standards and proactively identify those standards that correlate with information literacy.

Within this context of reform and change, Information Power (AASL & AECT,

1998) challenges library media specialists to reinvent our roles as teachers and as instructional partners. Certain assumptions are crucial in analyzing and acting

on these roles. They are:

• Learning is more than the what of discrete disciplinary content; it embraces the how and why of learning.

• There are commonalties across disciplines in terms of the processes and dispositions that motivate and drive the how and why of learning.

• The entire school community helps students master these processes and acquire dispositions that enable them to become responsible decision-makers and resourceful problem solvers.

• Library media specialists are potentially powerful catalysts and team members in this learning community.

This article revisits the following essential questions as it addresses how library

media specialists contribute to these learning communities:

• What is worth learning or knowing?

• How do students demonstrate this learning?

• How do we create environments that cultivate thoughtful learning?

Both theoretical explanations and practical examples are presented below. Past scholarship and records of effective practice are readily acknowledged throughout the piece.

What is worth learning or knowing?

Hester (1994) contends that the quality of learning is determined by the quality of the processes of thinking used in learning. Thinking, in this context, is essentially a problem solving process. He refers to creating “learning-ful” environments where students and adults come together and find meaning through their collective experiences (Hester, 1994, 4). His description of such environments overlaps with definitions of “thoughtful” learning communities posited by other educators (Barell, 1995; Fullan, 1993; Beyer, 1992).

The following characteristics of productive centers of learning emerge from these

various descriptions:

• Schools must perceive themselves as learning organizations where all stakeholders work at changing norms and habits to make meaningful learning real for students. They must build a shared vision and define student outcomes that bring life to that vision.

• The school vision should embrace the notion of empowerment; i.e., students are not controlled by the environment but are able to impact upon it through innovation and invention.

• The outcomes focus on a foundation of thinking. Thinking is defined as a cognitive process that connects bits and pieces of experience with other bits and pieces to establish relationships, to move from the simple to the complex.

This process grows and develops in learners so that they are capable of doing new things, not simply repeating what others have done (Hester, 1994).

• The concept of “thoughtfulness” is essential in a foundation of thinking (Tishman, Perkins & Jay, 1995; Barell, 1995). This involves not just the intellectual or cognitive operations but the feelings and attitudes that students have toward themselves as thinkers.

Glatthorn and Jailall (2000) further elaborate that curriculum based on the above premises exhibits depth rather than superficial coverage, emphasizes solving problems rather than simply acquiring factual knowledge, centers on contextualized problems rather than skills taught in isolation, and selectively integrates disciplinary content rather than maintaining a separation of subjects.

While different theorists have presented their own models and taxonomies of thinking (Marzano, 2001; Halpern, 1997; Barell, 1995; Hester, 1994; Ennis, 1992;

Beyer, 1992), certain thinking processes are reflected in all of them. They


• Perception and recognition of problems, of new data, and of patterns emerging from the data.

• Storage and retrieval of new data.

• Organization and transformation of data, identifying relationships between things.

• Reasoning, problem solving, deductive and inductive inference.

• Metacognition, assessment and monitoring for self-improvement.

Figure 1 expands on the process by identifying some of the strategies essential for thinking (Nahl-Jacobovits & Jacobovits, 1993; Beyer, 1992; Ennis, 1992).

–  –  –

Implications for practice: How do we enhance this learning?

Library media specialists are strategically positioned to work with entire school populations and to examine curriculum from a big picture perspective. We are not immersed in single content areas; instead, we have the advantage of working with classes in multiple disciplines. We have the opportunity to reflect with teachers on the essential ideas and modes of inquiry in the various subjects taught.

Based on the premise that a foundation in thinking permeates the disciplines, library media specialists are key team members in identifying the relationships existing between thinking skills and dispositions and the processes embedded in the disciplines and in information literacy (Stripling, 1995).

What might these skills look like in various disciplines? Here are several examples culled from my own classroom observations and from more formal analyses conducted by other scholars (Wiske, 1998; Spitzer, Eisenberg & Lowe, 1998; Dalbotten, 1997):

• In language arts--literary appreciation and analysis requires strategic use of language including being able to predict, validate, and synthesize. It also encourages analysis from multiple points of view and perspectives, and the ability to identify bias and stereotyping. Students are immersed in both literary and nonliterary modes of information. Active engagement is crucial.

• In social studies--historical analysis involves formulating questions, obtaining data from sources, testing these sources for their accuracy and authority, and detecting and evaluating propaganda and distortion. Students develop comparative and causal analyses and construct sound historical arguments.

They use resources ranging from primary documents and artifacts to virtual field studies found on the Internet.

• In mathematics--problem solving in mathematics challenges students to formulate problems, consider alternative strategies to solve them, and apply a strategy and verify the results. To accomplish these aspects of problem solving, they must be able to collect, organize and describe data; construct, read and interpret displays of data; and formulate and solve problems that involve data collection and analysis. Mathematical inquiry provokes students to make sense of ideas in relation to one another and to the everyday world.

The focus is on conceptual understanding, multiple representations and connections.

• In science—scientific inquiry necessitates that students understand key questions and concepts that guide scientific investigations. They must be able to formulate testable hypotheses, design and conduct the investigations, formulate and revise explanations and models using logic and evidence; and communicate and defend their findings. Students use a wide range of tools and make choices among alternatives. Carefully planned experiments can proceed in a predictable fashion or yield startling data that lead to new questions and investigations. The process is not random; it follows a purposeful sequence of testing, data collection and analysis, and drawing of conclusions.

• In information literacy--information searching and use assumes that problems and issues investigated require student engagement with information in different formats and for different purposes. Students must be able to articulate the focus of their information search, generate questions that probe the problem, consider alternative strategies to locate and retrieve data and to evaluate their value and relevance. Students also need to explore organizational schemes that help them store and use their information, and to hone their expertise with different communication formats.

Whether learners are performing a scientific experiment or a historical investigation, they are questioning, conjecturing, and searching for relationships to problems and issues. Figure 2 captures the cross-disciplinary nature of the thinking process.

–  –  –

Although self-improvement and reflection are most directly captured in the metacognition strand in Figure 2, the notion of thoughtfulness actually permeates the entire learning experience. That is, as students practice the skills of thinking, they must also recognize the attitudes they are developing toward themselves as learners. Questions such as “How did I know I was doing it correctly or well?” and “How confident am I in doing this again?” go beyond the cognitive operations and acknowledge the importance of affective responses.

Working together with teaching colleagues to examine curriculum from the perspective of thinking processes, also means that we as library media specialists must look deeply into the content of our own information literacy instruction. While various excellent information literacy models exist, the challenge for library media specialists is to reexamine the skills we have traditionally taught and to evaluate them in the context of developing thinking.

In this self-assessment, many of us may discover that we have focused largely on tasks at the mechanical levels of performance rather than at levels requiring manipulation of information and ideas. Examples of these traditional tasks


• Using an online catalog.

• Identifying the physical components of a resource (e.g., parts of a book).

• Locating materials within a specific library.

• Using an organizational scheme to take notes.

• Creating a bibliography.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 |

Similar works:

«DYNAMIC POSITIONING CONFERENCE September 16-17, 2003 FPSOs and Shuttle Tankers State of DP Development and Potential in Shuttle Tankers Kjell E. Helgøy Navion AS, Stavanger Return to Session Directory Kjell Helgøy FPSOs and Shuttle Tankers State of DP Development and potential in Shuttle Tankers STATE OF DP DEVELOPMENT AND POTENTIAL IN SHUTTLE TANKERS. 1. Brief History of DP development for shuttle tankers in the North Sea. Offshore loading in the Norwegian Sector of the North Sea was started...»

«Northwest Ethnobotany Field Guide Over fifty plants native to the Pacific Northwest including detailed information about historical and contemporary human-plant relationships Compiled by Devon Bonady Vaccinium ovatum evergreen huckleberry This project is based on the research and creative work of twenty students at the University of Oregon who enrolled in Environmental Studies 411: Northwest Ethnobotany during fall term 2011. They each created three profiles and accompanying creative work, much...»

«ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #1: SONS OF PERDITION Complete Script, THIRD DRAFT April 19, 2012 By Fred Van Lente / © 2012 Valiant ONE GENERAL NOTE: Throughout this Sumerian sequence, while there are some nods to historical accuracy, it is clear from the design that we are dealing with a pre-Cataclysm, pre-historical society far advanced than our own; they're using Kirby-style mythic hypertech.Some good reference for historical Sumer regardless: Sumerian Garb (& City) Ref.:...»

«Persuasive Ethopoeia in Dionysius's Lysias Author(s): Kristine S. Bruss Source: Rhetorica: A Journal of the History of Rhetoric, Vol. 31, No. 1 (Winter 2013), pp. 34Published by: University of California Press on behalf of the International Society for the History of Rhetoric Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/rh.2013.31.1.34. Accessed: 04/03/2014 17:03 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at....»

«THE USE OF FOREIGN SOLDIERS DURING THE TAIPING REBELLION Alex Gouzoules By the year 1860, the Taiping Rebellion had been raging across China for over a decade. The largest civil war in history had turned the once fertile and prosperous Yangzi Delta, especially the area between the rebel capital Nanjing and the treaty port of Shanghai, into a bloody wasteland. A British Quartermaster General described the misery of the area when he wrote, “the distress and misery of the inhabitants were beyond...»

«Einstein as a Student Dudley Herschbach Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA Abstract Late in life, when reflecting on his uncanny papers of 1905, Einstein liked to say, Nobody expected me to lay golden eggs. A century later, nobody can expect to fully comprehend how he did it. Yet much is known about Einstein as a student, enabling us to trace his maverick path as a fledgling scientist. It was a rough path; even with his talent and...»

«HELLENISTIC ASTROLOGY AS A CASE STUDY OF „CULTURAL TRANSLATION‟ By MOONIKA OLL A dissertation submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of MPhil(B) in Classics and Ancient History Institute of Archaeology and Antiquity College of Arts and Law University of Birmingham September 2010 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or...»

«CHAPTER 3 GREEK AND HELLENISTIC CIVILIZATION CHAPTER SUMMARY The chapter begins by stressing the importance of the ancient Greeks to the history of Western Civilization. Although Greek civilization was centered in the lands surrounding the Aegean Sea, the Greeks spread their culture throughout the Mediterranean area and even into the Black Sea region, coming into contact with the older civilizations of the Near East. This chapter also surveys the political and cultural history of the Greek...»

«Network Analysis of Beowulf, the Iliad and the Táin Bó Cúailnge Pádraig Mac Carron and Ralph Kenna Applied Mathematics Research Centre, Coventry University, England. January 2013 Abstract Mythological epics frequently entail plethoras of characters in timeless narratives beyond documented history. As such, they differ from legends couched in definite historical timeframes and intentionally fictional folktales. The concept of universality is important to comparative mythology and it has been...»

«Machiya and Transition A Study of Developmental Vernacular Architecture John E. Linam Jr. Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Architecture Bill Galloway, Chair Dr. D. Kilper Dr. J. Wang November 30, 1999 Blacksburg, Virginia Keywords: Machiya, Japan, Vernacular, Architecture Thesis Proposal John Linam, Jr. 411.57.8532 C AU S + VP I MACHIYA AND TRANSITION A Study of...»

«On the Hallowed Hill: An Analysis of Historic Cemeteries within the Great Smoky Mountains National Park A Thesis Presented for the Master of Arts Degree University of Tennessee, Knoxville Jacqueline A. Lott August, 2000 Acknowledgements I would like to thank a number of people for their kind support and generous assistance. First and foremost, I would like to thank my thesis committee, for their guidance and suggestions. Without their help, I would have spent a great deal more time wondering...»

«Reflecting on ‘Classic Television’: Making and Remaking Television Classics, 20 March 2009, University of Warwick Rachel Moseley writes: Most people have a sense of what might count, for them, as ‘classic television’. From long-running serial drama like Coronation Street, to Sunday evening dramas such as Upstairs Downstairs and Pride and Prejudice, or the nostalgic pull of 1960s children’s programming like Pogles’ Wood, the term has great resonance in relation to one’s personal...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.