FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 7 |

«University of Bristol Department of Historical Studies Best undergraduate dissertations of Rose Farrell The Civil Defence Hiatus: A Rediscovery of ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

University of Bristol

Department of Historical Studies

Best undergraduate dissertations of

Rose Farrell

The Civil Defence Hiatus: A Rediscovery of Nuclear Civil

Defence Policy 1968-1983

PDF processed with CutePDF evaluation edition www.CutePDF.com

In June 2009, the Department of Historical Studies at the University of

Bristol voted to begin to publish the best of the annual dissertations

produced by the department’s 3rd year undergraduates (deemed to be those

receiving a mark of 75 or above) in recognition of the excellent research work being undertaken by our students. As a department, we are committed to the advancement of historical knowledge and understanding, and to research of the highest order. We believe that our undergraduates are part of that endeavour.

This was one of the best of this year’s 3rd year undergraduate dissertations.

Please note: this dissertation is published in the state it was submitted for examination. Thus the author has not been able to correct errors and/or departures from departmental guidelines for the presentation of dissertations (e.g. in the formatting of its footnotes and bibliography).

 The author, 2009.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted by any means without the prior permission in writing of the author, or as expressly permitted by law.

‘The Civil Defence Hiatus’1 A Rediscovery of Nuclear Civil Defence Policy 1968 - 1983 Candidate Number: 32694 Word Count: 12,082 A dissertation submitted in accordance with the structure of the Historical Studies BA, Bristol University, April 2009 Lawrence J. Vale, The Limits of Civil Defence in the USA, Switzerland, Britain, and the Soviet Union, (Hampshire, 1987), p. 138 Contents Introduction 3 Part One Civil Defence after 1968 11 Chapter One The Paradox: Did Civil Defence after 1968 Abandon Civilians? 11 Chapter Two The Alternative: Was Civil Defence a Method of Political Control after 1968? 19 Part Two Civil Defence after 1983 29

Chapter Three:

The Anomalous Decade: Did Civil Defence from 1983 Reflect a PreEthos? 29 Conclusion 37 Bibliography 39 Introduction

–  –  –

The Cold War left behind a world which was so littered with apocalyptic weapons that even the most powerful man in today’s politics cannot make an immediate change. President Barack Obama’s reaction to the recent launch of a nuclear missile from North Korea has once again opened up debate on nuclear weapons. Obama pledged his commitment to proliferation, but he admitted that this process would be so slow that it would be impossible during his lifetime. The most worrying consequence of this continued threat is terrorism. “One terrorist with a nuclear weapon could unleash massive destruction”.3 Research into the Cold War is important for two reasons. Firstly, the decisions made during the Cold War are still resounding in society today. An understanding of the reasoning behind previous government’s policies has the potential to equip us for the long path towards solving the nuclear problem. Secondly, research so far has been considerably stunted by the amount of information that is available to historians. Secrecy was the “potent weapon” of the Cold War; the mystery of the enemy’s political prowess formed the crux of political tension.4 This has lead to a mix-match of complex, and often very conflicting, ideas on the exact nature of government plans during this enigmatic period. As time passes after the end of the Cold War in 1991, new information is reaching the public. It is important that this new information should be applied to these tangled debates in the hope of eventually finding resolution.

Britain’s role in the Cold War was peripheral; the two main proprietors were the capitalist USA and the communist Soviet Union. This did not mean that Britain was safe from nuclear attack; its geographical proximity to the Soviet East meant that it was used as a storage base for American nuclear weapons,5 making it a likely fighting Webb, J. ‘Obama Promotes Nuclear Free World’, Sunday 5th April 2009.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/7983963.stm Ibid.

Nick McCamley, Cold War Secret Nuclear Bunkers: The Passive Defence of the Western World during the Cold War, (Barnsley, 2007), p. 279 Bob Clarke, Four Minute Warning: Britain’s Cold War, (Gloucestershire, 2005), p. 9 ground should warfare have begun. There were two government policies aimed at defending the British population from nuclear attack. The first was nuclear deterrent, which was a product of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO). “Deterrence means transmitting a basically simple message: if you attack me, I will resist”.6 This meant that each country fought the other through scientific potential alone. The destructive capability that this policy produced reached such high levels that if one side attacked, it was likely to have caused Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD). 7 It is this legacy that is still affecting world politics. The second policy was civil defence;

this was “precaution other than combat taken to protect the civilian population”.8 The relationship between the two policies is ambiguous; some argue that civil defence undermines the policy of deterrence, as deterrence is based on building enough weapons that Britain was no longer vulnerable to attack.9 Others say that civil defence can work together with deterrence, in order to enhance Britain’s ‘invulnerability’.10 This study will focus on the latter protection policy: civil defence plans. Although, because both the defence policies are linked so ambiguously, the policy of deterrence will inevitably feature in some of the debates.

Civil Defence played a crucial role during the Blitz. The main asset of this policy was the Civil Defence Corps, which was governed by a philosophy of ‘rescue and succour’. They were a trained group of volunteers who laboured long hours to dig survivors out of blast destruction.11 In the jubilation of victory, the CDC was disbanded at the end of the war. However, it was reinstated again as part of the Civil Defence Act of 1948, when tensions arose between the USSR and the USA.12 It soon became clear that a nuclear war would be very different to a conventional war; this was forcefully demonstrated to the western powers when the USSR tested their first

M. Quinlan (Ministry of Nuclear Deterrence Theorist), quoted in Gwyn Prins, Defended to Death:

Study of the Nuclear Arms Race from the Cambridge Nuclear Disarmament Seminar, (London, 1983), p. 172

Suzanne Wood, ‘The Illusion of Protection’, in Dorothy Thompson (ed.), Over our Dead Bodies:

Women Against the Bomb, (London, 1983), p. 50 Greville Rumble, The Politics of Nuclear Defence: A Comprehensive Introduction, (Oxford, 1985), p.

Prins, Defended to Death, p. 255 Vale, The Limits of Civil Defence, p. 146 Clarke, Four Minute Warning, p. 156 W. Cocroft and R. Thomas, Cold War: Building for Nuclear Confrontation 1946 – 1989, (Swindon, 2003), p. 229 thermonuclear powers in 1953.13 ‘Fallout’ was discovered in the same decade. The blast of a nuclear bomb would be so powerful that it would create a cloud of toxic radioactive dust.14 This made the concept of rescue difficult – people would not be able to help after an attack without endangering themselves in the process. The Defence White Paper in 1957 admitted that conventional civil defence would be useless against nuclear weapons,15 and then the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962 demonstrated that a nuclear war could be possible within a very short space of time.16 Civil defence as it had been during the war was no longer adequate, and the last dregs of the World War Two system disappeared after the abandonment of the CDC in

1968.17 Civil Defence spending costs also plummeted from £22 million per year to just £7 million.18 The outdated policy was replaced with a new cheaper concept if civil defence, driven by a ‘state rationale’ philosophy. Rather than focusing on rescue, the policy now turned to making the structure of regional government stronger after an attack. The new system split the country into core compartments, so that each individual region would be able to function without the help of central government.

The country was sectioned into eleven Home Defence Regions (controlled by a Regional Commissioner), and each of these was split into twenty-three Sub-Regional Headquarters, which would include County Controls and District Controls. 20 It was thought that the public would be safer in their own homes during an attack, so they were told to ‘Stay At Home’ for fourteen days.21 They would be given advice on how to build a fallout shelter inside their homes, and that they should not move districts otherwise their county would not help them.

There are two documents that have recently been released on the topic of Cold War civil defence. These sources are particularly valuable, given that the area is so devoid of documented source material. The first source is a Home Office document containing the details of the Protect and Survive ‘Mass Information Campaign’ Clarke, Four Minute Warning, p. 157 Peter Hennesy, The Secret State: Whitehall and the Cold War, (London, 2002), p. 131 Campbell, War Plan UK, p. 121 Hennesy, The Secret State, p. 154 Clarke, Four Minute Warning, P. 165 Hennesy, The Secret State, p. 139 Hennesy, The Secret State, p. 144 Rumble, The Politics of Nuclear Defence, p. 168 Clarke, Four Minute Warning, p. 73 planned and written by the government from 1973 – 1975.22 Released in 2005, the campaign was formed of television adverts and radio scripts. The campaign would have been opened to the public should international relations have deteriorated far enough. It was aimed at providing information to householders on how to protect themselves against a nuclear attack. The Protect and Survive booklet was the only part of the campaign to be released to the public, in 1980. It caused a huge amount of scepticism for the way it presented a potential nuclear situation and the advise it gave to householders. The most powerful criticism is illustrated, literally, in Raymond Briggs’ Where the Wind Blows, where an elderly couple die of radiation poisoning despite following ‘govern-mental’ advice.23 Moreover, the Protect and Survive television adverts from the campaign were aired in a BBC Panorama programme in February 1980. 24 The second source is also a Home Office document that was released earlier in 2008. It contains discussions between the government and the BBC from 1973 – 1975 regarding radio procedure after an attack.25 The BBC had a minibroadcasting studio in every regional government bunker; therefore they would be on the front line of maintaining communication after an attack.26 Because this document has been released very recently, it has not been included in any research so far.

McCamley was the last to publish research into this area in 2007, before the release of this document. Peter Hennesy claims that these Home Office documents are the “crown jewels of genuine official secrecy”.27 However, it must be remembered that these sources shed light on only a tiny part of government policy during this period.

The government retains strict control over what is released to the public. Most information is “almost without exception closed for at least a hundred years” under the Official Secrets Act.28 It is clear that a full analysis of government policies during the Cold War is something that will only be possible for historians in the future.

Despite this, they might help us begin to challenge historiography.

London, Public Record Office, HO 322/776 Raymond Briggs, When the Wind Blows, (London, 1986), p. 38 John Minnion & P. Bolsover, The CND Story: The First 25 Years in the Words of the People Involved, (London, 1983), p. 35 London, Public Record Office, HO 322/775 Peter Laurie, Beneath City Streets: A Private Enquiry into the Nuclear Preoccupations of Government, (London, 1970), p. 113 Peter Hennesy, quoted in ‘’Nuclear Secrets of 1975 Revealed’, 29th December 2005.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 7 |

Similar works:

«Handle with Care An investigation into the care system HARRIET SERGEANT CENTRE FOR YOUNG POLICY STUDIES 57 Tufton Street, London SW1P 3QL 2006 THE AUTHOR HARRIET SERGEANT is the author of three widely-acclaimed and influential reports: Welcome to the Asylum: immigration and asylum in the UK (Centre for Policy Studies, 2001); No System to Abuse: immigration and health care in the UK (CPS 2003); and Managing not to Manage (CPS, 2003). She has also written three books: Between the Lines:...»

«Western Kentucky University TopSCHOLAR® Masters Theses & Specialist Projects Graduate School 5-2014 The Broad, Toiling Masses in all the Continents: Anticolonial Activists and the Atlantic Charter Mark Reeves Western Kentucky University, mark.reeves915@topper.wku.edu Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.wku.edu/theses Part of the Asian History Commons, European History Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Reeves, Mark, The Broad, Toiling...»

«The characteristics of millisecond pulsar emission: I. Spectra, pulse shapes and the beaming fraction Michael Kramer1, Kiriaki M. Xilouris2, Duncan R. Lorimer1, Oleg Doroshenko1, Axel Jessner1, Richard Wielebinski1, Alexander Wolszczan3, Fernando Camilo 4 ABSTRACT The extreme physical conditions in millisecond pulsar magnetospheres as well as their different evolutionary history compared to “normal pulsars” raise the question as to whether these objects also differ in their radio...»

«Agrekon, Vol 47, No 2 (June 2008) Jordaan & Kirsten Investigating alternative governance systems for the South African mohair supply chain D Jordaan and J Kirsten 1 Abstract Mohair is an exclusive natural animal fibre with niche market appeal. It is, however, questionable whether it is inherently suited to a commodity-based marketing system in a marketing environment that requires marketing systems to convey far more information than commodity-based systems do. Historically, mohair has been...»

«ABSTRACT Title of Document: THE CONSTRUCTION OF U.S. CAMPTOWN PROSTITUTION IN SOUTH KOREA: TRANS/FORMATION AND RESISTANCE Na Young Lee, Ph.D., 2006 Directed By: Professor Seung-kyung Kim Department of Women’s Studies This dissertation examines the historical construction and transformation of U.S. camptown prostitution (kijich’on prostitution) in South Korea. Wrought by Japanese colonialism, U.S. military occupation, national division, and the Korean War, camptown prostitution has been...»

«Boredom in the Workplace: A new look at an old problem Mary L. Cummings Duke University Fei Gao Massachusetts Institute of Technology Kris M. Thornburg United States Coast Guard Precis: This article reviews historical and recent efforts in boredom research and related fields. It introduces a systems-based framework, called the Boredom Influence Diagram, that describes various elements of boredom and their interrelationships. Areas for future reseach are highlighted including experimental and...»

«A Vanquished Peace? The Success and Failure of Conflict Mediation in the Democratic Republic of the Congo 1 Gerrie Swart University of Stellenbosch, South Africa Abstract The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) has endured a long, difficult and brutal chapter in its 52year history of independence, including one of the most brutal wars Africa has witnessed to date. The aim of this article is to consider the various challenges that continued to severely undermine the DRC’s successful...»

«Narrating family histories: Negotiating identity and belonging through tropes of nostalgia and authenticity Abstract Studying change is at the heart of any investigation into social life, whilst continuity is seen as central to a stable identity over time. Change is an unsettling, but inevitable, part of everyday life; continuity speaks of repetition over time, unity and the comfort of belonging. This paper examines how themes of nostalgia and authenticity are evoked in telling family histories...»

«CITY OF HOUSTON Archaeological & Historical Commission Planning and Development Department LANDMARK DESIGNATION REPORT LANDMARK NAME: Arthur R. Holliday House AGENDA ITEM: Ia OWNERS: Maire Albiol & David Baldwin HPO FILE NO.: 06L127 APPLICANTS: Same DATE ACCEPTED: 07-15-06 LOCATION: 3000 Del Monte Drive – River Oaks HAHC HEARING DATE: 08-24-06 30-DAY HEARING NOTICE: 07-20-06 PC HEARING DATE: 08/31/06 SITE INFORMATION Lots 14 and 15, Block 32, River Oaks Subdivision, Section One, City of...»

«The Flag of the City of Buenos Aires: Four Centuries of History Francisco Gregoric Abstract Even though the City of Buenos Aires, capital of the Argentine Republic, is more than 400 years old, the flag that represents it has just a 30-year history and was only adopted officially 15 years ago. However, the flag’s central emblem can be traced to the founding of the city in 1580 by the Spanish conqueror Juan de Garay, who gave the city its first coat of arms. But in its early times this emblem...»

«The Bessarabia-Maps in IL-2 A Readme by Jörg Wiedemann © 2007 Ray Grützmacher Bessarabia Readme Introduction This file is meant to provide the some background information for creating missions which depict the historical events as close as possible. We tried to make the map as close to reality as possible with our limited resources. Weather & time of year Most military action took place in spring and summer during 1941’s axis as well as 1944’s soviet advance. The map is designed for...»

«Password Security: A Case History Robert Morris Ken Thompson ABSTRACT This paper describes the history of the design of the password security scheme on a remotely accessed time-sharing system. The present design was the result of countering observed attempts to penetrate the system. The result is a compromise between extreme security and ease of use.INTRODUCTION Password security on the UNIX† time-sharing system [1] is provided by a collection of programs whose elaborate and strange design is...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.