FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 |

«Meeting Report Hosted by Groupama Asset Management, Paris, France Organised by Implementing Responsible Investment A United Nations Investor ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Implementing Responsible Investment

A United Nations Investor Roundtable

Paris, June 16, 2004

Meeting Report

Hosted by

Groupama Asset Management, Paris, France

Organised by

Implementing Responsible Investment

A United Nations Investor Roundtable, June 16, 2004

Groupama Asset Management, Paris, France

Meeting Report

Editor: James Gifford

UNEP Finance Initiative, July 2004

© 2004 UNEP Finance Initiative

Implementing Responsible Investments


Executive Summary


Extra-financial analysis and investment processes

Materiality of social and environmental risk in oil and gas

Environmental and social issues for the global insurance sector

Responsible investment and fixed income portfolio management

Shareholder engagement: does it make a difference? What are the financial impacts?...... 14 Shareholder Engagement: Morley’s Engagement Processes

Shareholder Engagement: Investor Perspective

Responsible investment in emerging markets

Emerging Markets: Investor Perspective

Constructing an Emerging Markets Portfolio


Closing Remarks

1 Executive Summary On June 16, the Asset Management Working Group of UNEP Finance Initiative held an Investor Roundtable ‘Implementing Responsible Investment’ in Paris, hosted by Groupama Asset Management. The 40 participants included pension funds from across Europe, consultants, analysts and representatives from the member firms of the Working Group. The

key points that were realised from the meeting included:

Environmental, social and corporate governance issues are clearly material – especially over the long term – and companies and their investors who do not take these issues into account do so at their own peril.

These issues must be brought into the mainstream and firmly integrated into the work of all players, whether they be investors, fund managers, brokers, investment consultants or companies themselves.

Collaboration by investors in their shareholder engagement activities is essential to achieve improvements in corporate behaviour in order to address the risks and opportunities posed by environmental, social and corporate governance issues. There is a clear need for a global alliance of investors to collaborate across borders to bring about this change.

Research, education and the upgrading of skills to address these issues is required on a global basis. There is significant experience with engagement processes in a small number of countries, and this experience can form the basis of a global collaboration.

There are significant opportunities involved in responsible investment in emerging markets, but more research, better information and regulatory frameworks are required to minimise the risks.

Please note: this report should be read in conjunction with the slide shows that were used during the presentations.

They can be downloaded from http://www.unepfi.net/pensions

–  –  –

Introduction CARLOS JOLY, Co-Chair, Asset Management Working Group;

Storebrand At the ExxonMobil AGM on May 26th, a revealing exchange took place between Lee Raymond, ExxonMobil chairman and CEO, and Dale McCormick, the Treasurer of Maine.

When Mr. McCormick asked a question about how the company accounts for liabilities related to climate change regulations on its balance sheet, Mr. Raymond replied: ‘The potential liabilities of climate change are neither likely nor can they be estimated’.

Those of us in asset management who are members of the UNEP FI believe that Raymond is wrong to be dismissive and McCormick is right to ask the question. Climate change risks, other environmental risks, social risks, workplace risks and relations with society do count and are increasingly becoming reflected in equity pricing. The decisions of institutional investment managers like us make that so.

The question is not if environmental, social and corporate governance considerations (ESG) are material but rather when, under what conditions, by how much, the timing and what the appropriate corporate response should be.

In the UNEP FI Asset Management Working Group, we are 12 asset management companies with diverse ways of incorporating ESG into portfolio composition, into engagement with companies and into fundamental company analysis.

There are a number of serious issues relating to ESG:

Excessive claims as to effectiveness of the approach from SRI activists.

Risks and opportunities are exaggerated.

If the ESG company ranking was sufficiently predictive of equity performance, we would not require fundamental company analysis. In fact, ESG is a way of enriching, adding insight and perspective to traditional equity analysis and a way of increasing the confidence or forcing questions about its conclusions. It is no substitute.

One thing we have all felt lacking is sufficiently robust analytic insight into ESG matters from our broker analysts. Hence, a year ago we established a project to invite our brokers to conduct specific research to be shared with the public.

We suggested issues that we thought were relevant but left it up to the brokers to decide on the particular criteria of relevance in their sector.

We reviewed, summarised and interpreted the findings.

–  –  –

We are organised collegially, and work through monthly conference calls, yearly gatherings, emails and phone calls.

We have the support of a capable, professional secretariat.

–  –  –

Extra-financial analysis and investment processes Eric Borremans, Head of SD Research, BNP Paribas Asset Management The slides for this presentation can be found at http://unepfi.net/pensions

–  –  –

Extra-financial criteria for the automotive industry Corporate governance The role of family/state shareholders.

Fuel economy Smog, CO2 and particulate emission standards are becoming more stringent. Some manufacturers are well ahead and some well behind – this will have a financial impact.

New technologies (hybrids, fuel cells) There are big differences between manufacturers in terms of research and development, prototypes and commercialisation.

End-of-life vehicles Manufacturers are currently required to set up recycling infrastructure in all EU member states. This requires investment – some are making provisions, others are not.

Work time flexibility To what extent does the car manufacturer have the ability to accommodate peaks and troughs in production rather than laying off people, causing disruption and losing corporate knowledge?

Pension liabilities For example, for the US car manufacturers.

Employment practices in the supply chain Manufacturers have thousands of suppliers in various regions and there are reputational 5 Implementing Responsible Investment, June 2004, Paris issues associated with the way employment practices are managed within the supply chain.

Why would we see those issues become more relevant to investment decisions?

Well-governed companies tend to outperform poorly governed companies, a trend exacerbated by financial scandals.

More stringent legislation such as CO2 trading schemes.

Changing consumer preferences.

Increasing NGO pressure.

Extra-financial analysis is not meant to be a substitute for financial analysis – it is meant to provide a more complete view of investment risks and opportunities.

Building extra-financial analysis into investment processes The danger with traditional SRI screening is that it not only restricts the fund manager but it also brings with it an inherent conflict of interest between SRI researchers who want to keep stocks out and the fund manager who wants to bring them back in.

Ultimately, we will achieve the systematic integration of environmental, social and governance issues into fundamental analysis. This could be implemented by incorporating a risk premium into the growth rate or cash flow when the materiality of the issue in question becomes clear – e.g., when stringent regulation or CO2 emission allowances are introduced.

However, the full integration of these issues into financial models may be going too far too fast. Company valuation models are very sensitive. Modifying the growth rate or risk premium by a few basis points may lead to large differences in valuation.

At this stage, we decided it was best to run the environmental, social and governance analyses and the financial analyses in parallel. This allows us to get to know the issues and the companies better and build internal capacity and knowledge.

Challenges include:

Acceptance of these issues by financial analysts who do not feel confident with these issues because they are not easily quantifiable;

Access time with companies: one-hour meetings are not sufficient to discuss questions of extra-financial issues. Extra time, however, is very beneficial because it enables financial and extra-financial analysts to see each other’s points of view.

–  –  –

Materiality of social and environmental risk in oil and gas Anthony Ling, Co-Director of European Research, Goldman Sachs Anthony Ling’s presentation is based on the Goldman Sachs report, Introducing the Goldman Sachs Energy Environmental and Social Index, which can be found at http://www.unepfi.net/stocks/ The slides for this presentation can be found at http://www.unepfi.net/pensions/ There is really is a tremendous degree of interest in this report not just within the investment community but also within the corporate world. Many companies, however, are still struggling to understand what the investment community wants from them.

Main points:

BP is the stand out leader, both in terms of their reporting and their management relative to the rest of the industry.

Exxon also does well. American companies perform very badly on climate change but they are relatively outstanding on management diversity, operational excellence etc.

There is a proliferation of second-tier European players Statoil, Norsk Hydro, British Gas, Total – all of them performing significantly better than their US peers.

One-off events or NGO-led campaigns have little impact on share prices other than in the very short term.

–  –  –

The production mix itself is changing from OECD to nonOECD countries. Operating in non-OECD and developing countries is an absolute must for these companies if they are going to succeed.

Projects are getting bigger. The scale of everything has gone up dramatically.

–  –  –

The industry is facing a resourcing crisis. The number of people employed in the US oil industry fell by 30% between 1980 and 1999. The number of people employed in upstream operations has halved over that period. The average age of an upstream employee is now 45. It is extremely difficult to attract new people into the industry. We are asking for more from a reduced workforce and in a more competitive environment.

It is a more transparent industry. Many developing countries want to improve their performance. They are signing up to transparency initiatives. NGOs are having an effect, operating either on their own or together with SRI funds to raise issues, be it Nigeria or pipelines through Azerbaijan and Turkey. The industry cannot ignore these issues.

Environmental awareness is increasing. When you go to do business in a non-OECD country such as Kazakhstan or West Africa, companies cannot get away with poor environmental practice the way that they used to.

An understanding of climate change and its impact on the growth of the gas and renewables industries is essential for success.

Companies like BP and Shell are looking forward 15–20 years. They understand that if the gas industry globalises, it will have a fundamental impact on the structure of the energy industry.

It is the absence of US companies in the index that says something about the success factor of the issues we have outlined today. These leading European companies are managed in a much more sophisticated way. They have the same capital bases as the US companies, and the same technology, maybe less. It is in the way that they are managed that has helped them produce outstanding results, not just now but also in the foreseeable future.

Relative to Exxon, the leading European companies have significantly outperformed.

However, Exxon is changing. They have gone from being nowhere in the gas industry to second behind Shell and on a parallel with BP in terms of exposure to next generation gas assets. If you look at issues other than climate change such as diversity of workforce, number of females employed, safety track record, R&D, investment in the environment, you see a very different Exxon. One glaring area of omission was on climate change and gas, and there is no doubt in our opinion that they have worked that out and that they are a changing if not an already changed entity.

Revealing the ultimate truth about company behaviour is almost impossible, especially in countries like Nigeria. How can you penetrate from the outside to really find out what is going on?

The buy-side community must increase the amount of important it places on these issues in broker polls. Analysts are unlikely to research these issues without being rewarded.

–  –  –

Environmental and social issues for the global insurance sector Volker Kudszus, Associate Director, Insurance Research Analyst, West LB Equity Markets This presentation was based on the West LB report Insurance and Sustainability: Playing with Fire, which can be found at: http://www.unepfi.net/stocks/ The slides for this presentation can be found at http://www.unepfi.net/pensions/

Main points:

After conducting this study, it was clear that there are many links between insurance, climate change, gene tech and geopolitical risk.

Climate change related claims double every decade. We found the biggest impact is business interruption. The reason most insurers do not care about this if they know that the claims are rising is that most of the business is short-tail business. They can therefore adjust their premiums every year.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 |

Similar works:

«Henry G. Overman, Stephen Gibbons, Sabine D'Costa, Giordano Mion, Panu Pelkonen, Guilherme Resende and Mike Thomas Strengthening economic linkages between Leeds and Manchester: feasibility and implications: full report Report Original citation: Overman, Henry G. and Gibbons, Stephen and D'Costa, Sabine and Mion, Giordano and Pelkonen, Panu and Resende, Guilherme and Thomas, Mike (2009) Strengthening economic linkages between Leeds and Manchester: feasibility and implications: full report. The...»

«THE ART AND ECONOMICS OF INTERNATIONAL NEGOTIATIONS: HAGGLING MEETS HURRYING AND HANGING ON IN BUYERSELLER NEGOTIATIONS Abstract This paper offers a theoretical model which focuses on cultural bargaining behavior. It is based on an intercultural negotiation framework of activity-based cultural types (Ott, 2011). The complexities of international negotiations are analyzed from a multi-active bargaining perspective which considers negotiation-is-an-art model. The results show the multi-active...»

«Core Idea: CONNECT Engage the wider world. Strengthening the International Development Institutions July 9, 1965 Adlai Stevenson II’s Speech before the United Nations Economic and Social Council Geneva, Switzerland Excerpt: We travel together, passengers on a little space ship, dependent on its vulnerable reserve of air and soil; all committed for our safety to its security and peace; preserved from annihilation only by the care, the work, and I will say, the love we give our fragile craft....»

«Host and co-sponsors: Host Co-Sponsors Financial contributors: Gold Bronze Abt Associates China Medical Board BMJ Rockefeller Foundation BMZ Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development, Government of Germany Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Global Health Research Initiative, Canada Silver HRP (Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human Reproduction), WHO Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research Management Sciences for Health International...»

«Secretary of Finance SECRETARY OF FINANCE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF FINANCE Location: 1111 East Broad Street, 3rd Floor Richmond, Virginia 23219 Tel. (804) 786-1148 Fax (804) 692-0676 Internet: www.finance.virginia.gov Richard Brown Gina Burgin R. Neil Miller Connie Biggs 129 SECRETARY OF FINANCE The Secretary of Finance provides guidance to the four key agencies within the Finance Secretariat. These agencies handle all the financial transactions of the Commonwealth — from collecting taxes...»

«Supply and Demand for Finance of Small Enterprises in Ghana Supply and Demand for Finance of Small Enterprises in Ghana Supply and Demand for Finance of Small Enterprises in Ghana Ernest Aryeetey Amoah Baah−Nuakoh Tamara Duggleby Hemamala Hettige William F. Steel Copyright © 1994 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/THE WORLD BANK 1818 H Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A. All rights reserved Manufactured in the United States of America First printing June 1994...»

«Nobility among the Austrian economic elite in 2008. PHILIPP KOROM & JAAP DRONKERS Last update 12 October 2009 Paper presented at the invited workshop ‘Nobility in Europe during the 20th Century: Memories, Loyalties and Advantages in Context’, hosted by the European University Institute, Florence, 15-16 June 2009. Nobility among the Austrian economic elite in 2008 Philipp Korom & Jaap Dronkers Abstract This article deals with 16642 members of the Vorstand, the Aufsichtrat and the...»

«Spring and Summer 2013 Volume 11, Number 1 Effective Leadership for Sustainable Development Rene Akins Bert Bright Tracey Brunson Woody Wortham University of Phoenix Abstract This study provides perspectives of 13 organizational leaders, executives, and business owners who are third year doctoral learners from the University of Phoenix. This research focused on the perspectives of leadership qualities they deemed necessary for effective leadership. These professional leaders offered insights...»

«Trainer’s manual A training course on setting up and running a banana tissue culture nursery Moses Lule, Thomas Dubois and Daniel Coyne International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) Dan Kisitu, Herbert Kamusiime and Joseph Bbemba Volunteer Efforts for Development Concern (VEDCO) With contributions from Vinzenz Bauer and Volker Hoffman, Universität Hohenheim Peter Mwirigi, Peter Mwaura, Losenge Turoop and Esther Kahangi Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology Edward...»

«Loyola University Chicago Law Journal Volume 26 Article 2 Issue 3 Spring 1995 1995 Wild Card Statutes, Parity, and National Banks The Renascence of State Banking Powers Christian A. Johnson Assist.Prof., Loyola University Chicago, School of Law Follow this and additional works at: http://lawecommons.luc.edu/luclj Part of the Banking and Finance Law Commons Recommended Citation Christian A. Johnson, Wild Card Statutes, Parity, and National Banks The Renascence of State Banking Powers, 26 Loy. U....»

«APRIL 10, 2014 “Compound interest is the eighth wonder of the world. He who understands it, earns it. he who doesn't. pays it” – Albert Einstein Dear Investor, The first quarter of 2014 was uneventful for most major financial markets. There was no shortage of world news, but investors exhibited little concern. This lack of reaction was notable given the widespread worries of a reversal from last year’s significant rise in asset prices. For the quarter, U.S. equity markets were...»

«Creative Space By Peter Lloyd Updated April, 2009 © 2001-2009 Peter Lloyd Asked to decide what they need in order to perform more creatively, employee teams invariably include at the top of their list a stimulating space devoted to creative work. Allowed to design and furnish their own creative space, they also make excellent choices—choices confirmed by those who have designed successful creative spaces. Yes, I mean to suggest that if you want to make space for creative work, the collective...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.