FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Dissertations, online materials

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

«Value of the Yanchep Caves: Assessing Yanchep National Park Visitor's Willingness to Pay for Environmental Improvement to the Caves James Perriam1, ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Value of the Yanchep Caves:

Assessing Yanchep National Park Visitor's

Willingness to Pay for Environmental Improvement

to the Caves

James Perriam1, Sorada Tapsuwan2, Michael Burton1

and Steven Schilizzi1

School of Agricultural Resource Economics, University of Western Australia

CSIRO Land and Water

February 2008

[Insert ISBN or ISSN and Cataloguing-in-Publication (CIP) information here if required]

Enquiries should be addressed to:

Dr Sorada Tapsuwan CSIRO Land and Water Private Bag 5 Wembley WA 6913 Australia Tel + 618 9333 6730 Fax + 618 9333 6211 Email sorada.tapsuwan@csiro.au Copyright and Disclaimer © 2008 CSIRO To the extent permitted by law, all rights are reserved and no part of this publication covered by copyright may be reproduced or copied in any form or by any means except with the written permission of CSIRO.

Important Disclaimer CSIRO advises that the information contained in this publication comprises general statements based on scientific research. The reader is advised and needs to be aware that such information may be incomplete or unable to be used in any specific situation. No reliance or actions must therefore be made on that information without seeking prior expert professional, scientific and technical advice. To the extent permitted by law, CSIRO (including its employees and consultants) excludes all liability to any person for any consequences, including but not limited to all losses, damages, costs, expenses and any other compensation, arising directly or indirectly from using this publication (in part or in whole) and any information or material contained in it.

Acknowledgement This work was funded by the Gnangara Sustainability Strategy and CSIRO Water for a Healthy Country Flagship.

The authors gratefully acknowledge the ongoing advice and assistance from the members of the Gnangara Sustainability Strategy Taskforce, the Department of the Environment, Yanchep National Park and the University of Western Australia.

i Contents Summary

1. Introduction

2. Study site

3. Literature review

3.1 Previous valuations of caves and environmental assets on the Gnangara Mound.. 6

3.2 Economic techniques for valuation of environmental goods

3.2.1 Revealed preference method

3.2.2 Stated preference method

3.3 Survey and sampling techniques

3.3.1 Survey method

3.3.2 Hypothetical market scenario

3.3.3 Payment vehicle

4. Methodology

4.1 Questionnaire design

4.2 Population, sample and survey mode

4.3 Survey implementation

4.4 Statistical analyses

5. Results

5.1 Descriptive statistics

5.2 Bivariate probit results

5.3 WTP and revenue estimates

6. Summary and conclusion


Appendix A – Sample questionnaire

Appendix B

ii List of Figures Figure 1 Location of Yanchep National Park

Figure 2 Number of visitors to Yanchep National Park and Crystal Cave per year

Figure 3 Sample of a DBDC question

Figure 4 WTP probability response function for Park entry and cave entry fee

List of Tables Table 1 WTP bid amounts used for the three survey versions

Table 2 Summary of demographic data

Table 3 Summary of Yanchep National Park and caves visits

Table 4 Summary of attitudinal questions

Table 5 Results of the bivariate probit model for the park

Table 6 Results of the bivariate probit model for the caves

Table 7 Proposed entry fees for the Yanchep caves

–  –  –

SUMMARY Climate change is threatening valuable ecosystems all over the world with extinction. In most cases, preserving or restoring these affected ecosystems requires continual efforts that come at a significant cost to society. Under resource constraints, often the decision about which system to preserve artificially must be made in conjunction with social values. This paper tackles this important issue of eliciting societal preferences over artificially maintaining threatened ecosystems at significant costs through a survey of visitors, and by applying a non-market valuation technique.

Caves in Yanchep National Park support important ecosystems, but their level of environmental quality is threatened by falling groundwater levels. The problem concerns a declining population of stygofauna, which are groundwater invertebrates that live in only seven of the cave water systems in Western Australia. Survival of these species requires the groundwater table to be high enough to fill the cave floor. However, the groundwater table has fallen below this optimal level. A decision has been made to ensure the survival of the stygofauna by artificially pumping water into the caves to raise the groundwater table.

The state government, through the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC), has invested $1.7M in developing a bore, a piping system, and a water-filtering system for the Yanchep Caves Recovery Project. On top of all the capital expenditure is the ongoing cost, which is estimated to be $110,000 per year. If there is no government subsidy for the ongoing costs of the pumping project, Yanchep National Park will have to raise funds from elsewhere.

This situation raises the question of whether visitors are willing to pay to support the project and to have an artificially maintained state of the environment.

A double-bounded contingent valuation method over two payment vehicles was used in this study to estimate how much visitors to the park are willing to pay towards preventing a further drop in the water level in the caves. The survey used double-bounded dichotomous choice questions to measure respondents’ willingness to pay (WTP) for higher entry fees to the National Park and the caves in order to meet the costs of the cave restoration project. The probit model estimated that the median WTP for park entry was $13.85, which represents an increase of $3.67 on the current adult entry fee. Median WTP for cave entry was $9.95, an increase of $3.45 on the current fee for adults. These increases would raise annual revenue by $184,800 per year for park entry, and $61,056 per year for cave entry. Although consistent with the 'user-pays' principle, raising the cave entry fee only will not, unfortunately, be sufficient to cover the ongoing costs of the restoration project of $110,000 (which includes electricity, general maintenance and replacement of parts). Yanchep National Park may have to consider raising the park entry fee to help supplement the cost. The model also indicated that WTP responses were influenced by visitors' perceptions of the restoration project, their confidence in its success, and whether or not they intend to visit the caves in the future.

–  –  –

1. INTRODUCTION Water systems in the Yanchep caves have dried due to the falling water table of the superficial aquifer on the Gnangara Mound. This is mainly due to reduced rainfall as a result of climate change, but also due to ongoing abstraction for urban water use, irrigation of agriculture crops, and water use by the pine plantation upstream of the caves (F Felton, DEC, pers. comm. 2006).

Groundwater Dependent Ecosystems (GDEs) that rely on the caves systems require access to groundwater to maintain their ecological structure and function. If the groundwater level, which is mostly fed by rainfall and recharge into the superficial aquifer, drops below a certain threshold, these species will have to adapt to less water or they will die. Unfortunately, it is unlikely Perth’s rainfall will increase in the near future; therefore the water demand for scheme water, agriculture, and the pine plantation from the Gnangara Mound will continue to impact the cave ecosystems.

–  –  –

The superficial aquifer is also tapped for bore water by horticulturists in a region south-west of Yanchep National Park, as well as homeowners, industry, local authorities, golf courses, etc.

Each year 66GL of groundwater is pumped from the Mound to irrigate horticulture crops in Wanneroo. Water usage from many of these irrigation pumps was not monitored until the recent implementation of the Metering Program, where commercial bores extracting over 0.005GL (or =5ML) per year are being issued with meters (DoE 2005). The program may help to reduce abstraction, but there is no other incentive, nor is there a penalty to encourage bore owners to reduce use.

The Yanchep caves are an important social good for both cave visitors and those who value their existence. The caves also hold significant environmental value, as they contain GDEs called root-mat communities. These are formed when tuart trees (Eucalyptus gomphocephala) send their roots into the cave pools and streams, creating a habitat for rare and often endemic organisms. These communities are under threat due to the falling groundwater table, and

–  –  –

several caves are already dry. Artificial recharge appears to be the only option for sustaining the Threatened Ecological Communities (TECs).

The government responded to the declining water levels by creating an Interim Recovery Plan (IRP) for the caves (English et al. 2000). The IRP recommended that the Caves Recovery team construct a pumping operation that will re-fill five caves with water from the superficial aquifer.

The objective is to reinstate and protect the TECs. Currently, several government departments are investigating future land-use options for the Gnangara Mound. This project is gathering and integrating ecological, economic and social information to determine the consequences of future groundwater recharge scenarios. The predicted outcomes will inform Gnangara Mound decision-makers as well as the community. The value the public places on the Yanchep caves is useful for this project, as it is indicative of the social value of the Gnangara Mound.

The Department of Water (DoW) has held several stakeholder workshops in order to improve Gnangara Mound management. The first was in November 2004, and participants decided a broad, long-term management strategy should be developed which integrated all state government agencies (URS 2005). A second study in 2005 focused on the social values attached to wetlands, caves and other groundwater-dependent ecosystems on the Gnangara Mound by government employees (state and local), and interest groups such as researchers and community groups (URS 2005).

The ecosystems were ranked by Image 2 Front entrance of Crystal Cave interview and workshop participants and placed into four categories of importance. Crystal Cave and Loch McNess were both placed in category 1, the highest overall in situ social values, while Water, Car Park, Twilight and Boomerang Caves (all as one feature) were in category 3. However, the raw data shows eight out of 10 participants placed these caves in the first category, with four of these people citing root-mats or research potential as reasons. This is significant, as it shows that once people are informed of the caves’ ecological importance, they perceive them as valuable.

Gilgi and Cabaret Caves were not included because they were dry at the time and therefore not linked to the Gnangara Mound. This is interesting because both Gilgi and Cabaret were named in the seven critical habitats fed by groundwater that contain root-mats (habitats critical to the survival of the TECs) in the IRP (English et al. 2000).

The third workshop discussed the artificial watering issue. This issue was supported by the government representatives, but several others believed it was simply a band-aid solution and that the cause of the problem should be addressed (Beckwith 2006). Interviewees were also asked to describe the social water requirements of the caves, which are the water characteristics required to maintain the social values (Beckwith 2006). For Crystal Cave, the common view was to improve water levels through re-watering in order to maintain the tourism/education social value of the cave (Beckwith 2006). For the other four caves, stakeholders felt research values should be maintained, but believed the lack of water would reduce social value for cave enthusiasts (Beckwith 2006).

To maintain water levels and aquatic communities, water is being pumped into the caves. This presents the problem of whether the public’s perceived value of the caves is high enough to justify this cost. The caves are public environmental goods, and the value of these types of goods cannot be measured by direct reference to any market price (Bateman et al. 2002). Nonmarket valuations have been developed to solve this problem.

Value of the Yanchep Caves • 3STUDY SITE

This valuation study will ask how much the public is willing to pay to artificially pump water back into the caves to maintain the water level. This is important for the environmental water allocation to the groundwater-dependent ecosystems, as it is often determined by the public’s perceived importance of the ecosystem relative to commercial interests. It is also possible that the public does not value water in the caves. This could be the case if the public’s recreation value is greater when the caves are dry and if this recreation value is higher than the conservation value.

The report begins with an introduction to Yanchep National Park and its caves. This is followed by a review of literature in terms of methodology and existing valuation studies. Specifically, non-market valuation techniques will be reviewed to determine a suitable choice for the Yanchep caves. Survey and sampling techniques, as well as the questionnaire design, are also explained in the following section. This is then followed by results from the survey and data analysis. The final section discusses the conclusion and offers suggestions for future research.


Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 6 |

Similar works:

«THE FAILURE OF NORTHERN ROCK: A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL CASE STUDY Edited By Franco Bruni and David T. Llewellyn Chapters by: Tim Congdon Charles A.E. Goodhart Robert A. Eisenbeis and George G. Kaufman Paul Hamalainen Rosa M. Lastra David T. Llewellyn David G. Mayes and Geoffrey Wood Alistair Milne Marco Onado Michael Taylor SUERF – The European Money and Finance Forum Vienna 2009 CIP THE FAILURE OF NORTHERN ROCK: A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL CASE STUDY Editors: Franco Bruni and David T. Llewellyn; Authors:...»

«Consumer Employment in the Health Care for the Homeless Setting: Promising Practices Introduction Numerous social determinants of health—including inadequate affordable housing, poor access to health care, unemployment, and low wages—drive the modern crisis of mass homelessness. While Health Care for the Homeless (HCH) providers properly focus their resources on meeting clients’ immediate physical and behavioral health needs, and often on securing housing, the employment-related needs of...»

«Oxford Farming Conference Speech – 7th January 2014 Caroline Millar Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen. Introduction I grew up on our family farm in Perthshire where as well as being involved outside helping on the farm, I played an active role in helping with the farmhouse bed and breakfast business. Growing up with a farming family who enjoyed welcoming tourists from all over the world onto their farm to experience farm life and to share knowledge about how crops are grown and livestock is...»

«Malawi Social Cash Transfer Program Baseline Evaluation Report July 8, 2014 Carolina Population Center University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
 123 West Franklin Street/ Campus Box 8120 / Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27516-2524 Malawi Social Cash Transfer Baseline Evaluation Report— July 8, 2014 Contributors UNC-CH: Sara Abdoulayi, Gustavo Angeles, Clare Barrington, Kristen Brugh, Sudhanshu Handa, Mary Jane Hill, Kelly Kilburn, Frank Otchere, Diana Zuskov CSR-UNIMA: Peter Mvula, Maxton...»

«ANNEX of the Commission Decision on the individual measure in favour of ACP countries, to be financed from the 10th European Development Fund Action Fiche for Minimising the Illegal Killing of Elephants and other Endangered Species MIKES 1. IDENTIFICATION Title/Number Minimising the Illegal Killing of Elephants and other Endangered Species MIKES CRIS number : 024-888 Total cost Total estimated cost: EUR 13 708 000 Total amount of EDF contribution: EUR 12 335 000 The action is co-financed in...»

«Alaska Commercial Fisheries – Alaska department of Fish and Game http://www.cf.adfg.state.ak.us/geninfo/geninfo.php Introduction The vast fishery resources of Alaska are of tremendous importance to the economies of the state and the nation. In 2003, commercial fishermen landed over 5 billion lb of fish and shellfish worth over $1 billion. These resources are self-renewing if properly managed, and it is the mission of both state and federal fishery management agencies to maximize the...»

«Ethics, Law, and the Exercise of Self-Command THOMAS C. SCHELLING THE TANNER LECTURES ON HUMAN VALUES Delivered at The University of Michigan March 19 and 21,1982 THOMAS C. SCHELLING did his graduate work at Harvard University immediately after World W a r I I and joined the Marshall Plan, first in Europe and then in Washington, D.C. H e taught at Yale University for five years, and became Professor of Economics at Harvard in 1958. Most of his work has been in the study of bargaining and...»

«REDMAN DISPUTES & INVESTIGATIONS GROUP Forensic Accounting – Royalty Compliance Auditing– Commercial Litigation JEFFREY D. REDMAN, CFE CURRICULUM VITAE PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE In 2010, Mr. Redman founded Redman Disputes & Investigations Group. Mr. Redman has more than 33 years of experience in Forensic Accounting, Royalty Compliance Auditing and Commercial Litigation. Mr. Redman has provided expert witness and consulting services in many types of projects, including breach of contract,...»

«1 Gerhard Graf* Do Unofficial Cash Uses threaten Official Cash Provision? Abstract In this paper the question is asked whether illegal or criminal activities which need cash for their execution threaten official cash provision of a central bank. The issue is looked at for the case of Germany. Two special cases of illegal or unofficial cash uses can be discerned. One is the use of cash for black activities, the other is the wide range of shadow economies beyond black economies which are assumed...»

«CONFIDENTIAL BONUS #1 Exclusive Bonus #1 The Confidential Prayer Manuscript to Release your Finances from the Grip of Spiritual Vampires Prepared Exclusively for Active Users of Prayer Cookbook for Busy People: 222 Golden Key Prayers to Open Heaven’s Back Door and Bring Answers in 10 Days or Less by Elisha Goodman, Author/Spiritual Coach WARNING Do not share this manuscript with “baby” Christians, No matter their church titles. It is only for mature Believers who can handle strong meat...»

«UNICEF Lesotho Situation Report Mid-year update: Situation Report #3 Reporting Period: 01 January to 31 July 2013 Highlights Health, Nutrition and Hygiene:  A total of 791 children with acute and severeacute malnutrition have been effectively treated with therapeutic nutrition commodities in 2012. Additional 2,059 moderately malnourished children received take home supplementary feeding rations in 2013.  In the districts mostly affected by the food emergency, a total of 343 community...»

«THOMMESEN FINC 3200-001 SYLLABUS (part 1) AUBURN UNIVERSITY 2014 Spring FINANCE 3200: Risk and Insurance [11787] Section 001: MWF 3:00 3:50 p.m. in Lowder 034 INSTRUCTOR: Mr. Sven Thommesen OFFICE: 317 Lowder Business Building OFFICE HOURS: MWF 10:00 – 11:00 a.m. or by appt. OFFICE PHONE: (334) 844-3004 EMAIL: thommsn@auburn.edu Teaching Assistant: We have not been assigned a T.A. for this semester. COURSE DESCRIPTION This course is an introduction to the principles of risk management and...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dissertation.xlibx.info - Dissertations, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.